WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) 鈥� Hunter Biden's ex-wife and a former girlfriend testified Wednesday in his about finding his crack pipes and other drug paraphernalia, and jurors saw photos of the president's son bare-chested in a bubble bath and heard about his visit to a strip club.
As the first lady sat in the front row, the courtroom grew quiet when Kathleen Buhle, who was married to Hunter for 20 years, walked in. She testified that she discovered her husband was using drugs when she found a crack pipe in an ashtray on their porch on July 3, 2015, a day after their anniversary. When she confronted him, 鈥渉e acknowledged smoking crack,鈥� she said.
The trial, about whether he lied on a gun purchase form in 2018 when he said he wasn't using drugs, has quickly become a highly personal and detailed tour of the mistakes and drug use of Hunter Biden, whose struggles have been tabloid fodder for years and were used publicly by Republicans, including in their stalled impeachment effort against the president.
The proceedings are unfolding as looms, and , who is deeply concerned about the health and sustained sobriety of his only living son. Prosecutors argue the photos, testimony and other evidence are necessary to show Hunter Biden's state of mind when he bought the gun.
Hunter Biden has been stemming from the purchase in October 2018. He鈥檚 accused of lying to a federally licensed gun dealer, making a false claim on the application by saying he was not a drug user and illegally having the gun for 11 days.
Jurors have seen the gun and the form at the center of the case, and they have heard from the former clerk who sold the weapon. The clerk, Gordon Cleveland, said he watched as Hunter Biden entered his name, address and other personal information on the form.
He said he was standing next to Hunter Biden when he began to answer a series of questions on the form with 鈥測es or no鈥� boxes to check. Hunter checked a box saying he was purchasing the gun for himself. Another question asked whether the buyer was 鈥渁n unlawful user of or addicted to鈥� marijuana, stimulants, narcotics or any other controlled substance.
鈥淗e wrote 鈥榥o鈥�,鈥� Cleveland said. He also testified that Hunter did not ask any questions or express any confusion about the question. He paid $900 in cash, telling Cleveland to keep the change 鈥� about $13.
Prosecutors have hammered the idea that Hunter Biden was a habitual user, unable to stay clean for long. Buhle testified that even before she found the drugs, she suspected he was using. He had been kicked out of the Navy after testing positive for cocaine.
鈥淚 was definitely worried, scared,鈥� she said. They have three children and divorced in 2016 after his infidelity and drug abuse became too much, according to her memoir, 鈥淚f We Break,鈥� about the dissolution of their marriage.
Buhle, who was subpoenaed, was on the stand for a brief 20 minutes. She remained composed but seemed upset as she recounted how she searched his car about a dozen times for drugs, whenever the children were driving it.
鈥淒id you ever see Hunter using drugs?鈥� defense attorney Abbe Lowell asked Buhle.
鈥淣o,鈥� she replied.
Then prosecutor Leo Wise asked Buhle how she knew Hunter was using drugs.
鈥淗e told me,鈥� she said.
Prosecutors also called Zoe Kestan, who testified under immunity about meeting Hunter Biden in December 2017 at a strip club in New York where she worked. During a private session, he pulled out a pipe and began smoking what she assumed was crack.
鈥淗e was incredibly charming and charismatic and friendly, and I felt really safe around him,鈥� she said. 鈥淚 remember after he had smoked it, nothing had changed. He was the same charming person.鈥�
Kestan detailed for jurors when she saw him use drugs, buy drugs, talk about drugs or possess drug paraphernalia. Prosecutors asked her where he stored his drugs and pipes, and she testified he kept them in pouches and other places, such as a sunglasses cases.
On cross-examination, Kestan acknowledged that she had no contact with him in October 2018, the period when he bought the gun.
Jurors were shown dozens of pages of Hunter Biden's written in 2021 after he got sober. And they heard lengthy audio excerpts from the book, which traces his descent into addiction following , Beau Biden, in 2015 from cancer. The memoir covers the period he bought the gun, though it doesn't mention the weapon specifically.
Lowell has said Hunter Biden's state of mind was different when he wrote the book than when he purchased the gun, when he didn't believe he had an addiction. And he's suggested Hunter Biden might have felt he had a drinking problem at the time, not a drug problem. Alcohol abuse doesn't preclude a gun purchase.
The Delaware trial comes after the collapse of that would have resolved the gun case and a separate California tax case. He's now facing a separate trial in September on .
Hunter Biden has since pleaded not guilty and has said he鈥檚 小蓝视频 unfairly targeted by the Justice Department, after Republicans slammed the now-defunct plea agreement as a sweetheart deal for the Democratic president鈥檚 son.
In Congress, Republicans have for months pursued an impeachment inquiry seeking to tie President Biden to his son鈥檚 business dealings. So far, GOP lawmakers have failed to uncover evidence directly implicating President Biden in any wrongdoing. But on Wednesday, House Republicans accused Hunter and the president's brother James Biden to Congress as part of the inquiry.
At his criminal trial, Hunter Biden's personal messages have been shown as evidence, including some that came from a laptop he left at a Delaware repair shop and never retrieved. In 2020, made their way to Republicans and were publicly leaked, revealing some highly personal messages about his work and his life 鈥� some that appeared in congressional hearings. He has since sued over the leaked information.
Jurors are also expected to hear from James Biden, who is close with Hunter and helped his nephew through rehab stints in the past. They will also get details on how Beau Biden's widow, Hallie Biden, became addicted to crack during a brief relationship with Hunter after her husband's death.
Hallie took the gun from Hunter and tossed it into the garbage at a nearby market, afraid of what he might do with it. The weapon was later found by someone collecting cans and eventually turned over to police.
First lady Jill Biden went to court for the third consecutive day to support Hunter, ahead of , who was in Europe to mark the anniversary of D-Day.
If convicted, Hunter Biden faces up to 25 years in prison, though first-time offenders do not get anywhere near the maximum, and it鈥檚 unclear whether the judge would give him time behind bars.
The trial is unfolding shortly after Donald Trump, the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, was in New York City. The two criminal cases are unrelated, but their proximity underscores how the courts have taken center stage during the 2024 campaign.
___
Long reported from Washington. Associated Press Writer Farnoush Amiri contributed to this report.
___
Follow the AP's coverage of Hunter Biden at .
Claudia Lauer, Randall Chase, Colleen Long And Michael Kunzelman, The Associated Press
